Filling the money pools… loading 20 years of California money
Our yardstick · California First scorecard
CALIFORNIA FIRST SCORECARD
Malia Cohen
Statewide office · graded on what the office did
What stands out
Score
84%
of Malia Cohen’s counted actions in this office aligned with California First: a D.
16 of 19 actions. An A needs 95%.
By subject
1 of 1
aligned on Bloat, the best subject. The worst is Infrastructure: 0 of 1.
Tap a subject tile to see only those actions.
Direction
−25 pts
further from California First between 2023–24 and 2025–26.
The score went from 100% to 75% of counted actions aligned.
Money
$6.7M
went into Malia Cohen’s 6 money pools in the state records.
Tap “Follow this money” to see who gave it.
Malia Cohen’s scorecard
16 out of 19 actions aligned with California First positions (84%).
An A needs 95%.
Total scoreD16 of 19 actions aligned
Over time: closer to or further from California First?
A100%2023–24 7 of 7
→
D75%2025–26 9 of 12
From 2023–24 to 2025–26 the score moved from 100% to 75%: 25 points further from California First. Each box is two years of this office’s actions; it needs 4 counted actions for a letter.
Actions that made this grade · tap a tile above to see one subject
19 shown, newest first
2026-09-15 • audit
Did not audit the Employment Development Department (EDD) or the DMV, even though she had told CalMatters she would look at both. She told the Los Angeles Times she skipped EDD because the Legislature was already reviewing it, and skipped the DMV because the Legislature and State Auditor were reviewing it. Assembly Republicans raised this in a Sept 2026 letter.
Her office's audit of Central California Women's Facility payroll (July 2018 to June 2021, $343 million) found weak separation of duties, improper payroll access for 11 of 30 employees, and 70 employees holding excess leave worth at least $1.85 million.
Fraud, waste and abuse
California FirstAudits that find waste
CohenAudited a prison's payroll and published the problems
Her office's audit of the Education Department's Prop 47 school grant program (July 2018 to June 2024, $139 million) found the money was spent as the rules allow, with no exceptions, and admin costs under the 5 percent limit.
Her office's audit of Department of Conservation payroll (Oct 2019 to Sep 2022, $188 million) found weak separation of duties, improper payroll access for 4 of 17 employees, and 57 employees over leave limits worth at least $606,952.
Fraud, waste and abuse
California FirstAudits that find waste
CohenAudited a state agency's payroll and published the problems
Said the 2026-27 state budget she must administer had changes meant to steady revenue, including broadening the tax base, and warned that without them California could face deep program cuts.
As Franchise Tax Board chair, directed the board's staff to return with an analysis of why fewer eligible people claim the CalEITC, Foster Youth and Young Child tax credits, and a plan to raise take-up.
Mailed notices to about 130,000 Californians who may be owed unclaimed property, matched against Franchise Tax Board records, after a Dec 2025 round of 100,000 letters that returned $30.4 million. She said the funds belong to Californians, not the state.
Taxes
California FirstState should not keep people's money
Her office's payroll audit of California State Prison, Sacramento (Oct 2019 to Sep 2022, $521 million in payroll) found weak separation of duties, about $97.9 million in projected improper or unsupported regular pay, and about $2.4 million in overtime problems.
Her office's audit of Department of General Services payroll (Oct 2019 to Sep 2022, $689 million) found $18.7 million in improper or unsupported regular pay in the projected sample, and $26.1 million in all identified and projected costs.
Fraud, waste and abuse
California FirstAudits that find waste
CohenAudited a state agency's payroll and published the problems
Released the state's annual financial report for the year ending June 2025 with a clean audit opinion, the first in eight years issued before the Governor's May budget update. Reports say it still came about 42 days past the usual nine-month deadline.
As chair of the State Lands Commission, called an emergency session and voted yes, 2-0, to authorize litigation to defend the 2020 consent decree and challenge Sable Offshore's federal order to restart offshore oil transport.
Infrastructure
California FirstEnergy built on time and on budget
Praised the Governor's veto of SB 414, which would have created a new Education Office of Inspector General to do forensic audits of charter schools, saying her office already has that audit power. She said she would work with lawmakers on stronger charter oversight.
Bloat
California FirstNo new agencies; but strong audits
Her office's payroll audit of the Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation (March 2017 to Feb 2020, $1.8 billion in payroll) found missing timesheets (about $412 million in projected unsupported regular pay), about $22.3 million in improper or unsupported overtime, and at least $40.3 million in excess leave balances.
Her office's first payroll audit of Caltrans (March 2017 to February 2020, $5.3 billion in payroll) found weak separation of duties, improper payroll access for 43 of 233 employees, and about $96.7 million in identified and projected leave and lump-sum pay problems.
Fraud, waste and abuse
California FirstAudits that find waste
CohenAudited Caltrans payroll and published the problems
Her office's payroll audit of Folsom State Prison (July 2018 to June 2021, $311.8 million in payroll) found weak separation of duties, 13 of 32 employees kept payroll system access they should not have, and about $3.7 million in projected leave credits not reduced after payouts.
Her office's payroll audit of the California Public Utilities Commission (July 2018 to June 2021, $375 million in payroll) found weak separation of duties, improper payroll system access for 14 of 39 employees, unreduced leave credits of $1.45 million, and 158 employees over leave limits.
Fraud, waste and abuse
California FirstAudits that find waste
CohenAudited a state agency's payroll and published the problems
As chair of the court-ordered Multi-Agency Charter School Audits Task Force, released a report with 20 recommendations for finding charter school fraud, after a San Diego case where 11 people were convicted over about $400 million.
Fraud, waste and abuse
California FirstAudits and fraud checks on school money
After a former Controller's Office employee pled guilty to three felony counts of grand theft of unclaimed property, said her office has zero tolerance, had asked the CHP to investigate, and had tightened its internal controls.
Fraud, waste and abuse
California FirstPenalties for fraud and theft
CohenAsked police to investigate theft by her own employee
Authorized an audit of Mendocino County's finances after the county board asked for help with late and possibly inaccurate financial reports. The July 2024 report found the county missed its deadlines for two years and listed internal control weaknesses.
Fraud, waste and abuse
California FirstAudits of local government spending