☕ Support
Years: fromto
America Firstfor California
Filling the money pools… loading 20 years of California money
Public record · State of California campaign filings
›
BALLOT FIGHT · BOTH SIDES TOGETHER

Prop 5 (2018)

The money pools in this fight took in $72M: $69M for YES and $3.7M for NO.

How big is that? The 15th biggest of the 70 grouped ballot fights with money since 2006. $72M is about $1.86 for every person in California. The YES side had 19 times what the other side had.

America First for California seal

What stands out

Yes vs. no
19 times
what the No side had: that is how much the Yes side raised.
Yes: $69M. No: $3.7M.
Biggest giver
24%
of the Yes money traces back to one giver: California Association Of Realtors ($16M).
Size
15th
biggest of the 70 ballot fights by money since 2006: $72M.
That is about $1.86 for every person in California.
WHAT THIS FIGHT WAS ABOUT

Prop 5 (2018); the same committee later helped pay for Prop 19 (2020)

Prop 5 would have let homeowners who are 55 or older, or severely disabled, carry their low property tax bill to a new home anywhere in the state, as many times as they wanted. Prop 19 was a later, changed version that also made many inherited homes get taxed at today's value.

How the vote went: Prop 5 failed 40.2% to 59.8%. Prop 19 passed 51.1% to 48.9%.

Paid for the YES side. Realtor groups paid for this side. For Prop 5, the California Association of Realtors' issues PAC gave about $10.2 million and the National Association of Realtors gave $3 million. For Prop 19, the California realtors' PAC gave about $40.4 million and the national group about $4.8 million.

The other side: On Prop 5, unions for public workers, teachers and firefighters raised about $3.3 million against it. On Prop 19, the No side raised about $240,000, with help from a Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association project.

Who was expected to gainSupporters said older and disabled homeowners (and, in Prop 19, wildfire victims) could move without a big tax jump. Opponents of Prop 5 said wealthier homeowners and the real estate industry would gain the most. For Prop 19, the official fiscal statement said local governments and schools could each gain tens of millions of dollars a year, growing over time, with most new state money going to fire protection.
Who was expected to payFor Prop 5, the official fiscal statement said cities, counties and special districts would lose about $150 million a year at first, growing to $1 billion or more a year, and schools would lose about the same. For Prop 19, opponents said people who inherit a home they do not live in would pay more, pointing to a state analyst estimate of about $2 billion a year in higher property taxes over time.

What happened next: After Prop 5 lost in 2018, the realtors came back with Prop 19 in 2020. Lawmakers put it on the ballot and the realtors dropped their own signature drive. It passed narrowly.

Where this comes from: Ballotpedia · Ballotpedia

The YES side: $69M

$69Mtook in $69M · spent $80M

Where this side’s money really came from

California Association Of Realtors $16M24%
Landlords and builders $15M22%
Jpmorgan Chase Bank $1.4M2.0%
Sadler Strategic Media, Inc. $212K0.3%
Jpm&m, Inc. $157K0.2%
Tech and app companies $13Kless than 0.1%
Unions $11Kless than 0.1%
Power and gas utilities $11Kless than 0.1%
$10Kless than 0.1%
Landlords and builders $9Kless than 0.1%
Many smaller givers $36M52%
Other named givers, each a small share $223K0.3%
Trail too long to follow $4Kless than 0.1%

The NO side: $3.7M

$3.7Mtook in $3.7M · spent $2.6M

Where this side’s money really came from

Unions $1.2M33%
County Supervisors Association Of California DBA California $100K2.7%
CA State Council Of Laborers $53K1.4%
United Domestic Workers Of America Operating Account $46K1.2%
International Association Of Fire Fighters, Afl-cio $27K0.7%
Groundworks Campaigns, Inc. $17K0.5%
$15K0.4%
Power and gas utilities $14K0.4%
Canal Partners Media $13K0.3%
Wealthy individuals $10K0.3%
Many smaller givers $1.8M48%
Trail too long to follow $182K4.9%
Other named givers, each a small share $226K6.1%

How we traced it. We start at the money pool and walk every money flow backwards, through parties and groups, until we reach a giver who is not passing along someone else’s money. When money from many givers mixes in one money pool, each giver gets a fair share of what flows on. “Many smaller givers” are gifts the state lists without a name we can follow, including everything under $100.

A money pool’s side comes from our research or from “Yes on” or “No on” in its name. Money pools we could not place are listed as “side not confirmed.”

The mapEvery dot is a money pool. Tap one to open it.
A money flow is the color of the money pool it pours from. Big dot = lots of money.
big givers groups & PACs ballot props politicians parties mailers
Point at a dot to see whose it is. Tap it to open it.
All months Each bar is one month of money. Tap a bar to see just that month on the map.