☕ Support
Years: fromto
America Firstfor California
Filling the money pools… loading 20 years of California money
Public record · State of California campaign filings
›
BALLOT FIGHT · BOTH SIDES TOGETHER

Prop 45 (2014)

The money pools in this fight took in $72M.

How big is that? The 17th biggest of the 70 grouped ballot fights with money since 2006. $72M is about $1.84 for every person in California. We have only found one side’s money pools so far, so this is not the whole fight.

America First for California seal

What stands out

One side only
$72M
is all we have found so far, and it is from one side.
The other side’s money pools are not in our records yet, so this is not the full picture.
Biggest giver
35%
of the No money traces back to one giver: Anthem Blue Cross ($25M).
That is 1.3 times what the next biggest giver, Blue Shield, put in.
Size
17th
biggest of the 70 ballot fights by money since 2006: $72M.
That is about $1.84 for every person in California.
WHAT THIS FIGHT WAS ABOUT

Prop 45 (2014)Failed 41.1% to 58.9%

It would have made health insurance companies get the state Insurance Commissioner's approval before changing their prices for people and small groups. It also called for public notice and hearings on price changes.

Paid for the NO side. Health insurance companies paid for this side. Kaiser Foundation Health Plan and WellPoint (Anthem Blue Cross) each gave about $18.5 million, Blue Shield of California about $12.4 million, and Health Net about $6.6 million. Ballotpedia lists about $57 million raised by the No side.

The other side: Consumer Watchdog (the group that wrote the measure), the California Nurses Association ($1.2 million) and donor Kathryn Taylor ($500,000) paid for the Yes side, about $3.2 million in all.

Who was expected to gainSupporters said people who buy health insurance would save $200 million or more a year from lower prices. Opponents said the lawyers who sponsored the measure could gain from a rule letting them bill for challenging prices.
Who was expected to payThe state's analyst said the state would have new costs to review prices, likely in the low millions of dollars a year in most years, paid by fees on health insurers. Opponents said the added red tape would raise costs for consumers.
Where this comes from: Ballotpedia

The NO side: $72M

$72Mtook in $72M · spent $58M

Where this side’s money really came from

Hospitals, doctors and health companies $25M35%
Hospitals, doctors and health companies $20M28%
Hospitals, doctors and health companies $19M26%
Hospitals, doctors and health companies $7.9M11%
GCW Media Services $200K0.3%
$99K0.1%
$65Kless than 0.1%
Hospitals, doctors and health companies $1Kless than 0.1%
Hospitals, doctors and health companies $691less than 0.1%
$672less than 0.1%
Many smaller givers $22Kless than 0.1%
Other named givers, each a small share $14Kless than 0.1%
Trail too long to follow $74less than 0.1%

How we traced it. We start at the money pool and walk every money flow backwards, through parties and groups, until we reach a giver who is not passing along someone else’s money. When money from many givers mixes in one money pool, each giver gets a fair share of what flows on. “Many smaller givers” are gifts the state lists without a name we can follow, including everything under $100.

A money pool’s side comes from our research or from “Yes on” or “No on” in its name. Money pools we could not place are listed as “side not confirmed.”

The mapEvery dot is a money pool. Tap one to open it.
A money flow is the color of the money pool it pours from. Big dot = lots of money.
big givers groups & PACs ballot props politicians parties mailers
Point at a dot to see whose it is. Tap it to open it.
All months Each bar is one month of money. Tap a bar to see just that month on the map.